Reading list in the making... suggestions, anyone?
21-01-2012, 12:52 AM
Reading list in the making... suggestions, anyone?
I made my start on my current path with mostly online stuff (Youtube, articles on various sites and suchlike) and have only started reading some of the "essential" literature relatively recently (last year sometime, for the most part). I'm presently in ownership of a decent number of hard (ok, paperback) copies of books directly or indirectly relevant to the main focus of this forum, which I've either read (but probably intend to read again), haven't or somewhere between. I've reached the point where I've somewhat overwhelmed myself with choice, so what better place to ask then here for outside opinions on such matters? Any say on what should be read first, last or in between would be welcome, as well as opinions on particular books.
I'll give the current status of each book, along with any comments if I've read or started on them. (I'm assuming most of these books probably have their own thread somewhere, so that won't be in any great detail).
The God Delusion (finished)
This was the first I read of any of the Four Horsemen. No particular comments off the top of my head right now.
God Is Not Great (finished)
Second on the aforementioned, and first and only of Hitchens' books I've finished thus far. I consider myself to have had a somewhat substandard education, but I take at least a small degree of pride in my vocabulary - pride which is inevitably wounded reading an author such as Hitchens. Quite a deal of information covered in this book, and when I read it again, I'll need to make a point of reading it with a computer nearby with Dictionary.com and Wikipedia tabs open.
Hitch-22 (partway through)
Started on this after the previous. Quite enjoyed what I read of it, and found it inspiring to read about someone who grabbed life by the throat as Hitchens seemed to. Got to a point, however, where it started to make me a bit light-headed from all the name-dropping and mentions of events that took place in his lifetime, with the assumption that the reader will be adequately familiar with what he's talking about. It's hardly a bad thing to say of an author that they assume a lot of their reader, but it can make for somewhat intimidating work.
Letters to a Young Contrarian (currently reading)
A short Hitchens book, dealing with the specific subject matter this one does? Don't mind if I do.
The Quotable Hitchens (haven't started)
Arguably (haven't started)
Freedom Evolves (haven't started)
Breaking the Spell (partway through)
As has been established, I read Dawkins and Hitchens before getting to this one. Those familiar with it will know it takes a different approach, and one which on the surface I believe to actually be more dangerous and subversive to religion than a frontal assault as the others take. That said, I got two or three chapters in before stopping. There were just enough insightful and smirk-inducing things said to keep me that long, but ultimately, all the hand-wringing became too frustrating. I know, I didn't stick with it until he really got down to business with all the things he intended at great length to do, but I kept thinking back to the very first thing touched upon in the Four Horsemen discussions - the part where Dennett talks about the (ultimately in vain) lengths he went to with this book to not be offensive, something which he then found to be "a mug's game".
The End of Faith (partway through)
Can't really comment much on this book. I started, and it seems to be of the good quality you'd expect from an award-winning book by an author such as Harris, but I was clearly burnt out on writings of this sort at the time after my recent reading of the other three Horsemen. I'll finish it at some point.
Letter to a Christian Nation (finished)
I love this book. Concise, punchy, and more or less everything you'd want in an atheist manifesto. Of course a lot of further reading will need to be done to round things out, but this seems like an ideal starting point. There are a few minor criticisms I'd have, and a few things I'd want to check up on, but all in all, a solid work as far as I can see.
The Moral Landscape (partway through)
I thought this was very well done to the extent that I've read it so far, but once it got to talking about the nuts-and-bolts neuroscience, I immediately felt out of my depth. Harris does a good job making subject matter like this accessible in my mind, but it's still a bit much for when I'm reading casually during downtime somewhere without 'net access.
The Demon-Haunted World (haven't started)
KJB 400th Anniversary Edition
At most, I've only ever had a nominal religious involvement, if any. Given the community that I'd like to count myself part of, however, I feel a certain obligation to have a better knowledge of this. I really don't expect my opinion to change much either way, I just want to have a good understanding of the book itself - it doesn't need to be said that arguments directed at the faithful need to be accurate if you want them to hit home.
Sense & Goodness Without God (partway through)
I've owned this one the longest of all. Got it quite some time back, it's been collecting dust for a while now. I'm mostly just curious to see if anyone here has read it.
...and that's all for now, unless I've forgotten something.
"Well, the Bible does say God helps those who help themselves."
"Nah, it doesn’t, actually – that’s from one of Aesop’s fables. The Bible says quite the opposite, in fact – many passages of being patient and faithful, and waiting for the Lord to decide if he wishes to assist."